Accidental Lives is the story of a man who is in a car accident which leaves him awake in the hospital with no memory of the past six months. Partially paralyzed, he struggles with not having the life he had planned. Tomorrow finds him in a strange apartment in New York City with no memory of the past six months. He cannot remember graduating college or his best friend. Every other day he finds himself waking in the previous world convinced that the day before and its world were merely a dream.

He finds himself attracted to a woman from the hospital that has a mystical belief system. He inadvertently discovers that what he is learning from her may actually work as he finds evidence in his New York world. One world offers his planned future and the other a love life.

Torn between what appears to be two dream worlds, he finds himself tortured for one to end. Eventually his New York world provides its own love. By chance, she is the exact same image as his love interest in the other world. As he falls for both, torment turns into fear that one will indeed end and prove only a dream.